Make an Appointment 
Step by Step Guide to Buying an Engagement Ring
Buying an engagement ring is one of the most meaningful purchases you will ever make, and it should feel exciting, not overwhelming. Alson Jewelers is a fourth generation, family owned jewelry store, and has been guiding Cleveland area couples through this process since 1931. Here is exactly what to expect, step by step.
Step 1: Set Your Budget
Before you look at a single diamond, decide what you are comfortable spending. Our team works with every budget and will help you understand where your money makes the biggest visual and quality impact, whether that means prioritizing a larger center diamond, a higher clarity grade, or a more intricate setting.
Step 2: Schedule an Appointment
While walk-ins are always welcome, engagement ring shopping is best done one-on-one. Schedule an appointment ensures a member of our team is ready to present diamonds and settings specifically suited to your preferences and budget
Step 3: Learn the 4Cs
Every natural diamond is evaluated on four characteristics: cut, color, clarity, and carat weight. Together, the 4Cs determine a diamond’s overall quality, and understanding them will help you shop with confidence. Cut has the greatest effect on a diamond’s brilliance, making it often the most important factor to consider. Alson only sells natural, GIA-certified diamonds, so every diamond comes with an independent grading report you can trust. Our team will walk you through each of the 4Cs so you know exactly what you’re looking at.
Read more about the 4 Cs
Step 4: Choose a Diamond Shape
Round brilliant, oval, cushion, emerald, pear-shaped, and radiant are the most popular shapes. Each one wears differently on the hand and pairs best with certain setting styles. This is a great step to explore in person or with photos of rings you or your partner already love.
Read more about diamond shapes
Step 5: Pick a Setting Style
Round brilliant, oval, cushion, emerald, pear-shaped, and radiant are the most popular shapes. Each one wears differently on the hand and pairs best with certain setting styles. This is a great step to explore in person or with photos of rings you or your partner already love.
Read more about diamond shapes
Step 6: Compare Diamonds Side by Side
During your appointment, you’ll compare several natural, GIA-certified diamonds side by side under the same lighting and magnification, evaluating brilliance, scintillation, cut, and shape proportions. A certificate only tells part of the story; seeing diamonds next to one another is how you’ll find the one that truly speaks to you.
This side-by-side approach is also the best way to judge size. Diamonds are measured by weight, not physical dimensions, so two diamonds of equal carat weight can appear very different in size. Prioritizing cut will always yield a more dazzling result vs. carat weight alone.
Step 7: Select or Customize the Setting
Once the diamond is chosen, you will select a setting from our bridal collection, or work with your bridal specialist on a custom design.
Step 8: Finalize the Setting and Sizing
Ring sizing and any last minute engraving or design details happen before the ring is ready for pickup.
Step 9: Protect Your Investment
We provide full appraisal documentation on every purchase. Having your ring properly appraised and insured from day one protects your purchase for the long term.
Why Buy an Engagement Ring at Alson Jewelers?
Alson Jewelers has served the greater Cleveland community for nearly 100 years. As a fourth generation, family owned business, our company has built its reputation on exceptional quality, trusted relationships, and a passion for fine jewelry. Our commitment to selling only natural GIA-certified diamonds, combined with personalized appointments, an extensive bridal collection, and in-house design capability, makes the engagement ring buying process one you can trust.
Ready to start? Schedule an appointment with one of our bridal specialists.
Explore Additional Resources
Diamonds 101: Your Complete Guide to Buying a Diamond
Buying a diamond is one of the most meaningful purchases you’ll ever make, and at Alson Jewelers, we’ve been guiding couples through this process since 1931. As a fourth-generation, family-owned jeweler in Woodmere, Ohio, we’ve helped thousands of Northeast Ohio families find the perfect diamond.
What First Time Engagement Ring Buyers Should Know
Shop confidently with this guide to what first-time engagement ring buyers should know before they buy, from the experts at Alson Jewelers in Cleveland.
Learn MoreLoose Diamonds vs. Pre-Set Engagement Rings: What's Better?
Learn the differences between loose diamond vs. pre-set engagement rings with this guide from Alson Jewelers, your bridal jewelry destination in Cleveland, Ohio.
Learn MoreRing Size Tips
Getting the perfect fit is just as important as finding the perfect diamond—after all, a symbol of forever should actually stay on your finger. Our guide simplifies the sizing process so you can ensure your ring is comfortable, secure, and ready for that "yes" moment.
Learn MoreEngagement Ring Metal Types
Choosing the right metal is about more than just color; it’s the foundation that holds your forever diamond in place. Dive into our guide to find the perfect metal that fits both your aesthetic and your daily lifestyle.
Learn MoreEngagement Ring Styles
From timeless solitaires to intricate vintage designs, finding the right setting is just as important as the diamond itself. Explore our curated guide to the most popular engagement ring styles to discover which aesthetic perfectly captures your partner's personality and your unique love story.
Learn More